Has America Always Had an Income Tax?
Myth

America has always had an income tax.

Has There Always Been a Federal Income Tax in America?

The first income tax in America was part of the Revenue Act of 1861. The first permanent income tax was put in place in 1913 as part of the 16th Amendment.

Before direct taxes like this, there were only tariffs. Those on the lower economic rungs felt this style of taxation was unfair as it meant those benefiting from industrialization weren’t “paying their fair share” and thus there was a lack of money for social programs.

The progressive-populist sentiment of figures like Lincoln, Bryan and the Roosevelts eventually won the income tax debate (with support from pro-government factions who wanted to recoup costs after the Civil War and WWI respectively), and tariffs began to be supplemented by the income tax (and other tax types like payroll taxes).

Today about 50% of American families pay little-to-no effective federal income tax. Meanwhile the increased federal income allows for the social safety-net programs established in the 20th century.

See PBS’s CrashCourse on economics for a clearer look at why we pay taxes, keep reading for an explanation of how America got an income tax.[1]

Why is there taxes? The history of taxes and the American income tax. Taxes: Crash Course Economics #31.

When I find a man who is not willing to pay his share of the burden of the government which protects him, I find a man who is unworthy to enjoy the blessings of a government like ours… – William Jennings Bryan

TIP: Taxes have always been a thing. America was founded over a battle of taxation versus representation. Despite the initial battle over taxation, the Constitution allows for taxation. The 1913 16th amendment (which amends the constitution) clarifies that this can extend to income taxes.

The First Income Tax in the United States of America

The first income tax was established by the Revenue Act of 1861 to help pay for the Civil War, it was a 3% tax on income over $800 (about $20,000 in 2014). A second Revenue Act of 1862 introduced the first progressive tax (the first tax was a flat tax, see flat tax v. progressive tax). These taxes expired, then in 1894 we get a small income tax when the “Free Silver” supporting Populist Party “demanded a graduated income tax” in its 1892 platform. The socialists of the day felt that the tax system, which was like a sales tax via tariffs, was unfair as it favored the wealthy. The Wilson-Gorman Act of 1894 imposed the first peacetime income tax of 2%, however the court case Pollock v. Farmers’ Loan & Trust Co. of 1895 struck down this ruling declaring (referring back to wording of the constitution about direct taxes, and stating a tax on income was a direct tax.)

The first permanent income tax wasn’t established until 1913 with the 16th amendment, the same year of the creation of the Federal Reserve.

The 16th Amendment Explained: The Constitution for Dummies Series.

TIP: If this sounds like the left and right in a battle between social programs and tax breaks for higher earners… then congratulations you are paying attention! If it sounds like a conversation over the role of government and individual liberty versus social justice… look at you, you are starting to get it! See our complex left-right political spectrum for more details. When Bernie Sanders says raise taxes for social benefits, and Trump says lower taxes, they are having the same conversation that was being had in 1862, 1894, 1913, etc, etc.

The First Permanent Income Tax and the 16th Amendment

In 1913 Congress proposed the Sixteenth Amendment, which states: “The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.” This allowed for the first permanent income tax in the United States of America.

The first permanent income tax was established in 1913. This consisted of 7 brackets ranging from 1% to 7% for income above $500,000 (about $11.86 million in 2014).

Income Tax Rates on Highest and Lowest Income Earners in US 1950-2010.

Income Tax Rates on Highest and Lowest Income Earners in US 1950-2010 in a Graph.

Rising Income Taxes Until WWII

Taxes rose from 1913 to 1917, jumping quickly to a top bracket of 67% for income over $2,000,000 ($36.68 million in 2014). In 1925 taxes fell again after paying off many WWI debts, but then rose again to a 1944 peak near the end of WWII.

In 1944, during WWII, the top income tax bracket for income above $5,000,000 ($84.45 million in 2014) was 94%, this helped to pay for WWII and helped recuperate the remainder of the costs of WWI. In comparison, England had a similarly high tax rate due to the war as well.

WWII to Reagan

Despite the conflict in Vietnam, taxes were reduced for the richest Americans from WWII to the Reagan era, however the top income tax bracket began to be applied to lower income groups, meaning that a much larger fraction of the population was paying the top tax rate.

During the Reagan era the top bracket taxes were cut to 28% above $29,750 ($59,000 in 2014). While the Reagan era greatly reduced the top tax rates, it greatly expanded how many would pay those rates.

Bush to Obama

Since the Reagan era the percentage of income paid by the top tax bracket has increased. The top tax bracket itself has also increased in the sense that the effective tax rate for the middle class has changed little, while the tax rate the very rich pay has gone up.

In 1991 President George H. W. Bush raised taxes by 3%, but pushed the top tax rate from $29,750 to $82,150 easing the tax burden on the middle class. President Bill Clinton made a similar change in 1993, (Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Acts of 1990 and 1993).

After this, President George W. Bush cut income taxes, but raised the top tax rate, giving many people a break. The American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012, signed under President Obama continued the basic theme of the Bush tax cuts, despite drawing criticism from Bush tax cut supporters.

100 Years Of Income Taxes – TheBlazeTV – REAL HISTORY.

Tax Brackets, Top Rates, Percentages, and Inflation

To understand how the income tax affects people we need to consider the number of tax brackets, the top tax rates, the amount of money that qualifies for each bracket, inflation, and the times. In other words, we may think a 94% tax rate is draconian, but the bottom rate was 23%, which was also high. The economics of WWII demanded a high cost of survival. America was supported at all costs. Tax was over $2.88M in today’s dollars, which paints a different picture than one might get as an immediate reaction.

Below is a chart from Wikipedia explaining the tax bracket over time. This can be verified against Taxfoundation.org.

History of income tax rates adjusted for inflation (1913-2010)
Number of First Bracket Top Bracket
Year Brackets Rate Rate Income Adj. 2014 Comment
1913 7 1% 7% $500,000 $11.86M First permanent income tax
1917 21 2% 67% $2,000,000 $36.68M World War I financing
1925 23 1.5% 25% $100,000 $1.34M Post war reductions
1932 55 4% 63% $1,000,000 $17.14M Depression era
1936 31 4% 79% $5,000,000 $84.45M
1941 32 10% 81% $5,000,000 $79.86M World War II
1942 24 19% 88% $200,000 $2.75M Revenue Act of 1942
1944 24 23% 94% $200,000 $2.88M Individual Income Tax Act of 1944
1946 24 20% 91% $200,000 $2.41M
1964 26 16% 77% $400,000 $3.03M Tax reduction during Vietnam war
1965 25 14% 70% $200,000 $1.49M
1981 16 14% 70% $215,400 $563k Reagan era tax cuts
1982 14 12% 50% $85,600 $211k Reagan era tax cuts
1987 5 11% 38.5% $90,000 $186k Reagan era tax cuts
1988 2 15% 28% $29,750 $59k Reagan era tax cuts
1991 3 15% 31% $82,150 $142k Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990
1993 5 15% 39.6% $250,000 $406k Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993
2003 6 10% 35% $311,950 $398k Bush tax cuts
2011 6 10% 35% $379,150 $396k
2013 7 10% 39.6% $400,000 $403k American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012

TIP: It is very hard to understand the significance of income taxes without diving into details on marginal tax rates and tax breaks and comparing that to other taxes families pay in practice. Learn more about how the progressive income tax system works.



Conclusion

America hasn’t always had an income tax and a permanent income tax was only relatively recently established in 1913.


References

  1. Inflation calculator“. Westegg.com. Retrieved Oct 31, 2015.
  2. Income Tax in the United States“. Wikipedia.org. Retrieved Oct 31, 2015.
  3. Sixteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution“. Wikipedia.org. Retrieved Oct 31, 2015.
  4. U.S. Federal Individual Income Tax Rates History, 1862-2013 (Nominal and Inflation-Adjusted Brackets)“. Taxfoundation.org. Retrieved Dec 29, 2015.
  5. Tax History, the Definition of Income Taxes, a Taxucation“. Efile.com. Retrieved April 28, 2016.


"America Has Always Had an Income Tax" is tagged with: Abraham Lincoln, Systems, United States of America


Vote Fact or Myth: "America Has Always Had an Income Tax"

Your Vote: {{ voteModel || 'no vote' | uppercase }}